County's high suicide rate results in teen screenings

By ALANA LISTOE - IR Staff Writer - 12/06/06

Montana has one of the highest rates of suicide among teenagers in the country, according to a presentation recently given to the Helena School District Board of Trustees.

And Lewis and Clark County has an even higher rate than the state.

The Helena Suicide Prevention Coalition — composed of 47 representatives from schools, public health, social services, mental health and concerned citizens — was formed to address that distressing fact and find ways to prevent suicide among local teenagers.

The coalition recently received a $30,000 grant from the Montana Department of Health and Human Services to help pay the salary of a community suicide prevention coordinator as well as a pilot program called TeenScreen.

The pilot program is a voluntary screening process that will determine whether a high school student is at risk for depression, suicide or other mental health problems. The consent of parents as well as the student is required for the screening.

TeenScreen is a computer- generated questionnaire that takes about 10 minutes and generates only a positive or negative outcome as it screens for risk factors or red flags. It is not a comprehensive suicide screening.

The questionnaire covers anxiety, depression, substance abuse and suicidal thoughts and behaviors. The program does not endorse any particular treatments but rather aims to identify those who may be at risk of attempting suicide.

Teens who have undiagnosed mental health illness face a serious barrier to well-being, success and learning. According to the TeenScreen Web site, approximately 750,000 teens in the U.S. suffer from depression, some so seriously it leads to suicide, the third leading cause of death amon teens. It adds that only a small portion of these students ever receive help or treatment for their depression.

If the outcome of the screening is positive, the student will have a brief clinical interview with a mental health professional. If that professional decides that a more complete evaluation is needed, he or she will be paired with a case manager and services in the community.

The screening focuses on sophomores at Capital High School, and it has yet to be determined how students will be identified for letters to families inviting the student to voluntarily participate in TeenScreen.

Superintendent of Helena Schools Bruce Messinger said, “We are taking small steps before we make it too big.”

Judy Griffith, the school district’s chemical prevention coordinator, has worked in suicide prevention for two decades and will help shepherd the process.

However, she along with the other teachers and administration, cannot be involved in the TeenScreen process to ensure student confidentiality.

Griffith said that TeenScreen has been implemented in 500 sites in the United States with the vast majority in them located in schools.

Mike Henderson, nurse and administrator of the disease control and surveillance for the County Health Department, said the coordinator’s job will be to focus on the whole effort the coalition.

Part of the application process requires candidates to write and submit a plan on how they will organize and meet all the objections of the coalition.

The goals of the coalition are to increase community screening for potential suicides, to increase community education about suicide, to assure that suicidal individuals can access treatment locally and finally, to improve advocacy for individuals at risk of completing suicide.

The coordinators job will also be to oversee TeenScreen to be implemented this spring. The number of students to be screened will be dependent upon the number of parents and students who agree to participate.

“We are at the beginning of the planning process,” Henderson said.

He added that he’d like to see this type of screening implemented in the high school as part of a routine health screening.


Not Yet Rated


Untitled Document Please login to enter comment :
*Member ID:
*Password:
  Forgot Your Password?
 

Click here to register
Reader Comments:

JohnC wrote on Dec 28, 2006 12:06 PM:

" Sorry Michelle about your losses, but whenever we look to solve a problem, we have to look at what is happening now, not what happened 22 years ago. And if you know that alcohol was the cause of the suicides in your past, I would think you would be on the same side as any group of people trying to stop the use of all of these mind-altering drugs. Whether the drug is prescribed by a psychiatrist, or whether it is self-administered such as alcohol, we all know people do things while on drugs that they wouldn't do if they were sober. Why do we think we can give children daily doses of mind-altering drugs and expect them to handle their life better than before? "

Michelle wrote on Dec 20, 2006 12:31 PM:

" To Garrison Clark: Your comments are ridiculous and maybe you should stop looking at current statistics and look back about 22 years at Helena's suicide rate. Helena had the highest suicide rate in the nation and I personally lost 5 friends in 1 year to suicide. They all attended Capital High and I know there were even more after that. People tried saying it was a pact, but unfortunately I feel that alcohol played a huge part in these kids decisions to kill themselves. So Mr. Garrison, Psychotropic drugs may play a part in children committing suicide, but I will almost guarantee you that alcohol and drugs play a much larger part. Needle in a haystack? I don't think so; especially in Helena. "

JohnC wrote on Dec 17, 2006 3:11 PM:

" CC you ought to check your facts and not hide the ones that go against your personal leanings. CDC published statistics show in 2001 that suicide accounted for 4.6 deaths per 100,000 in children aged 10-19. In 2002, the CDC reported 27.6 deaths per 100,000 as the result of motor vehicle crashes. What this means is that spending $1 on driver safety would be SEVEN times more effective than worrying about suicide. But then again, the drug companies and psychiatrists couldn’t rake in their billions by teaching driver safety! "

CC wrote on Dec 12, 2006 7:49 PM:

" TO: Garrison Clark. Respectfully, I suggest you learn what you are writing about before you begin to condemn that which, clearly, you are ignorant of. Suicide is among the top teen related deaths in the U.S. According to the CDC (that's the Center for Disease Control). In 2003 Anderson and Smith (National Vital Statistics Report 2003;52(9):1-86) determined that teen suicide accounted for the 3rd leading cause of deaths. There are numerous, methodologically sound studies, that also reflect this. As such, you are mistaken in your opinion 'suicide..like a needle in a hay stack'..how absurd. Additionally, you wrote "nearly sixty percent of the children who kill themselves are taking psychotropic drugs" Do you have a reference? Perhaps it would be helpful for me to add that many teens on psychotropic medications are taking them preciously because of reporting or displaying suicidal ideation. As such, those people are already at an increased risk of suicide. You imply that there is a direct causal relationship between suicide and medication utilization. That relationship is far more complex and nuanced than I will go into here. Except to say, your inference is misguided. Finally, your assertion that the bulk of suicides would be eliminated by cutting off medication as a treatment tool needs support. Can you, Mr. Clarke, provide the support for your comments? Or are you partaking in the very thing you decry in the article? An abscence of facts? You are entitled to your own opinion...but, not your own facts. I look forward to your reply. "

Garrison Clarke wrote on Dec 10, 2006 4:27 PM:

" TeenScreen marketers drone on and on about suicides being the third leading cause of teenage death. They never mention any numbers, like how many suicides there are out of how big a population of teens. This omission is not by accident. The percentage of suicides is very tiny; like a needle in a hay stack. They also omit the fact that nearly sixty percent of the children who kill themselves are taking psychotropic drugs. The very drugs TeenScreen victims end up taking. If they want to reduce the number of kids killing themselves they'd stop prescribing the drugs that cause kids to kill themselves. That would eliminate a bulk of the suicides. Apparently I'm not the only one objecting to this intrusion into our schools. Check out this petition: http://www.petitiononline.com/TScreen/ petition.html "


Text Size:
Small | Medium | Large

View/Post Comments
 Email this story
  Print this story
 Rate Article
 Share Article

submit to reddit Delicious Digg!