Woman says doll promotes Islam

By JAMIE KELLY - Missoulian - 12/13/08

MISSOULA — Is a child’s doll a promotional tool of Islam?

That’s what some people are saying about the Little Real Loving Baby Cuddle & Coo doll, which seems to utter a pro-Islam message, causing some outrage among parents around the country and here in Missoula.

“It was disturbing to me,” said Tina Dennison, whose daughter had been carrying around Baby Cuddle & Coo, made by Mattel, for about a year before Tina recently noticed the message.

So concerned was Dennison that she complained to several Missoula retailers, including the local Kmart on Brooks Street, which promptly took the baby doll off its shelves.

The doll plays three short recordings whenever it’s touched or approached. Two of the messages are innocuous enough, lots of infantile gibberish with “mama” as the only discernable word.

But the third recording seems to say, “Islam is the light.” Or at least that’s what some people are hearing.

Dennison and her friends swear they hear it clearly, and don’t want their children exposed to Islamic ideas.

“It’s inappropriate,” said Dennison. “Especially at Christmas. In our home, Jesus Christ is the light.”

The Missoulian spent some time at the Break Espresso cafe downtown on Friday, asking people to listen to the doll’s message. None of the people interviewed were aware of the controversy.

“I couldn’t determine what it was,” said Cliff Larsen, Democratic state senator from District 50. “I could hear distinct words. There are four or five. But I can’t make it out.”

When told what the baby allegedly says, Larsen laughed.

“We’re not indoctrinating our infants, are we?” he said.

Lizzie Bennett, sipping on a caffeinated beverage, took a long listen to the baby recordings.

“I can ride a bike?” she guessed after her second listening.

Ken Woodward, sitting with her, didn’t fare much better, even after listening three times with the doll practically in his ear.

“I still got nothing,” he said. “Yeah, ‘ride a bike.’ We’ll go with that one.”

For its part, Mattel has issued a press release about the controversy, denying that it is intentionally trying to infiltrate American homes with a pro-Islam message.

Instead, it’s all just one big phonetic mash-up that happens to sound like a sentence, the company contends.

“The Little Mommy Cuddle & Coo dolls feature realistic baby sounds including cooing, giggling and baby babble with no real sentence structure,” the company said in a written statement. “The only scripted word the doll says is ‘mama.’ There is a sound that may resemble something close to the word ‘night, right, or light.’

“Because the original soundtrack is compressed into a file that can be played through an inexpensive toy speaker, actual sounds may be imprecise or distorted.”

Others have claimed to hear the phrase “Satan is king,” though Dennison said she hasn’t personally heard it in the many dolls she’s listened to.

Snopes.com, the Web site that investigates urban legends, quickly surmised that there was no intention of inserting a pro-Islam or satanic message in the doll.

Robert Lewis, manager of the Missoula Kmart, said it’s likely the doll will be back on his shelves soon.

“More than likely, we’ll probably put it back on the shelf,” he said. “We did it, really, to appease a customer. Otherwise, it’ll just sit there in storage.”

On the Web

Click here to view the Missoulian's video of public reactions to the doll.

3.2 stars
Current rating: 3.2 with 9 ratings.


Untitled Document Please login to enter comment :
*Member ID:
*Password:
  Forgot Your Password?
 

Click here to register
Reader Comments:

1977clare wrote on Dec 13, 2008 1:07 PM:

" I'm pretty sure I heard the doll say "Paul is Dead." "

wonkerbean wrote on Dec 13, 2008 10:51 AM:

" To think we attacked them for this? We can't even understand the recording of our toys because we don't make them here anymore. Little kids that grow up to not hate some people is un-thinkable. "

MTRICH wrote on Dec 13, 2008 8:41 AM:

" You must be an awful parent or think very poorly of your child if you think a doll is going to lead your three year old to beliefs other than yours (that doesn't happen until they are teenagers and doesn't require a dolly). I might be more concerned that the doll speaks gibberish--that is just poor quality. I have listened and one word does sound like LIGHT to me. With knowing what the doll is SUPPOSED to be saying one could certainly start hearing it but then again after I point out the bunny shaped cloud you may suddenly see then Easter Bunny in the clouds too. Is that my Christian plot? You can hear it for yourself here: (may have to cut and past this one) http://www.kjrh.com/media/news/5/9/6/596fea34-a2d7-4eda-92c2-d840ead7c023/Lil_Mommie_Coo_Original_10K.mp3 "

Alfie wrote on Dec 13, 2008 8:37 AM:

" LOL... what next? Will this woman and the other Islamphobics be seeing the Star and Crescent in a snow formation on the mountain behind the University. If people would study Islam, and Islam For Dummies is a good place to start, they will see that Islam is just as peaceful as Christianity. Christianity has as many radicals and terrorists as Islam does, only Islamic terrorists are targeting the US. Christian terrorists, such as those who bomb abortion clinics and kill their doctors, target the same kinds of things that Islamic terrorists do, ideas. Let's study what Islam is really about, not what the press says it is. Missoula has the self imposed reputation of being the "center" of learning and culture in Montana. Such nonsensical news such as this shows how narrow minded and ignorant some people are there. This article is amazing to me. "

Opinionated wrote on Dec 13, 2008 8:33 AM:

" Since this doll is designed to be played with and listened to by children, doesn't it make sense to have a group of 'unbiased' children listen to it and find out what it is they hear? I mean it isn't going to impact a child, who hears it once or twice, when the only purpose they would have to hear it at that moment is to serve as translators for adults. Many times, over the years when I have been unable to understand a child, I ask other kids to tell me what is being said. I wouldn't want a toy that promotes negativity around my grandchildren, but rather than promoting a rumor and possibly devastating the reputation of a toy company, why not find out what the doll really says and give Mattel a chance to fix the problem and make the recording more distinct. We are living in a 'dangerous age', but in my 58 years and those I can remember my family talking about from their years, the most 'dangerous age' was that when McCarthyism was alive and well. "

ya_whatever wrote on Dec 13, 2008 8:32 AM:

" OMG.......... "

thedukeofhelena wrote on Dec 13, 2008 7:21 AM:

" I saw this story already in the Rapid City, SD news. Some lady in Mitchell, SD decided that the doll was saying "Islam is the light" and now people are freaking out. How much more ridiculous do things have to get? This is just pure insanity. I see the story is spreading like wildfire, now. "


Text Size:
Small | Medium | Large

View/Post Comments
 Email this story
  Print this story
 Rate Article
 Share Article

submit to reddit Delicious Digg!